The Pew Research Center report, "Is College Worth It?", explores public views on the value of a four-year college degree, and analyzes economic outcomes for young adults with and without a degree. The study utilizes data from various sources, including the U.S. Census Bureau and the Federal Reserve, and incorporates a survey of over 5,000 U.S. adults.
Main Takeaways:
-
Public Perception of College Value:
- Mixed Views on Importance: Only 25% of U.S. adults believe a four-year degree is very important for getting a well-paying job. Nearly half (49%) say it is less important now than it was 20 years ago, while 32% believe it is more important.
- Cost Concerns: Only 22% of respondents think the cost of a four-year degree is worth it even if loans are needed. A larger proportion (47%) believes it is worth the cost only if no loans are required, and 29% think it is not worth the cost at all.
-
Economic Trends for Noncollege Young Adults:
- Improving Outcomes: Over the past decade, young adults without a bachelor’s degree have seen increases in earnings and wealth, and a decline in poverty rates.
- Persistent Gaps: Despite these improvements, the earnings gap between those with and without a degree has not narrowed significantly. Young adults with a bachelor’s degree still earn substantially more than those without.
-
Labor Market Participation:
- Gender Differences: Young men without a college degree have experienced a long-term decline in labor force participation, although this trend has stabilized in recent years. Young women, however, have seen steady increases in labor force participation over the past few decades.
- Full-Time Employment: The share of young adults working full-time year-round has increased since the Great Recession, especially for those without a college degree.
-
Earnings and Poverty:
- Earnings Trends: Earnings for young men without a college degree have increased over the past decade but remain below their levels from the 1970s. For young women, earnings have been more stable and have increased in recent years.
- Poverty Rates: Poverty rates have declined significantly for young adults without a college degree. For example, the poverty rate for young men with a high school diploma decreased from 17% in 2011 to 12% in 2023.
-
Household Income and Net Worth:
- Household Income Growth: Median household income for young adults without a college degree has risen over the past decade. However, the income gap between college graduates and non-graduates remains large.
- Net Worth Increases: The net worth of households headed by young adults, regardless of educational attainment, has increased significantly over the past decade, driven by factors such as rising home values and savings during the pandemic.
Policy and Practice Recommendations:
- Enhanced Support for Noncollege Pathways: Given the mixed public views and the economic trends, there is a need for enhanced support for alternative education and training pathways that do not require a four-year degree.
- Focus on Affordability: Addressing the high costs of college and providing more affordable education options can help alleviate concerns about the return on investment in higher education.
- Labor Market Reforms: Policies aimed at improving job quality and wages for workers without a college degree can help reduce economic disparities and enhance overall economic well-being.